Additionally the junub, from the analogy, is similar to this new menstruating people as they each other enjoys an enthusiastic impurity that needs ghusl
– Rasulullah (S) believed to tell all women (menstruating rather than) to come to the latest Eid prayer, however, he told you “allow the menstruating ladies avoid the prayer put.” -Rasulullah (S) inside said, “The newest mosque is not let getting menstruating girls or anyone who is within your state regarding janabah (intimate impurity).”
2) Sure She will be able to Stay in New MASJID (minority view stored of the Ibn Hazm, Al-Muzani a student of your Shafi’I madhab, Dawud Advertising Dhaahiri, and modern day students for example Shaykh Yusuf al Qardawi and you can others)
Evidences: -The fresh new hadeeth in the list above (“The latest mosque isn’t enabled for menstruating female otherwise whoever is within a state out-of janabah (intimate impurity)
”) is classified due to the fact da’eef (weak) by the Shaykh al-Albaani along with other students, therefore it is not permissible to make a commanding out-of fiqh considering a weak hadth. – This new ayah these are the fresh new junub can not be placed on brand new menstruating ladies since they’re maybe not analogous. Whenever Aisha is on the girl several months throughout Hajj, Rasulullah (S) told her “fit everything in but do not manage tawaf of your own kabah” and therefore ways she you can expect to stay at the brand new Kabah and manage worship, dua, an such like. -A servant woman who had been freed developed an effective tent and you will stayed in the new masjid. And you can Umm Mihjaan (the caretaker of masjid) carry out continuously take care of the masjid, and you will wasn’t told to cease they during menses. -Therefore, these types of scholars are of the opinion when they was basically very impermissible to possess a female not to ever stay-in this new masjid, there would be a genuine head hadith or ayah about any of it, since ladies within the live messenger regularly had the period. Read More